A 12-Step Program to Truly Good Corporate Governance

by Charles M. Nathan for The Harvard Law School Forum, May 18th, 2011.

Good corporate governance is of the moment. It is talked and written about constantly by academics, the corporate governance community working for institutional investors and proxy advisors, boards of directors, corporate executives, corporate lawyers, judges, reporters and, yes, even politicians. Indeed, it is talked about and written about so often and at such length that it often seems to tower above all other aspects of the corporate world. The discourse, moreover, has come to resemble something of a Tower of Babel, where so much is said, from so many points of view, that it seems impossible to make sense of it all.

This essay attempts to bring some coherence to the topic by positing a 12-Step Program that we believe would lead to a useful and effective paradigm for truly good corporate governance.

Step One: Start at the Beginning — The Proper Goal of Corporate Governance is to Enhance Value Creation for Shareholders

The literature and lore of corporate governance has become so complex and complicated that most of us tackle corporate governance issues on a relatively detailed level. We too often deal with the proverbial trees, not the proverbial forest. For example, we debate ad nauseam the merits of proxy access, or the optimum frequency of say-on-pay advisory votes or the utility of say-on-pay advisory votes. We worry about whether directors should be selected by majority voting instead of plurality voting, and how to frame a director resignation policy to deal with directors who fail to receive a majority vote under either system. We wrangle about whether poison pills should ever be allowed, and if so, whether they should be restricted to a one- or three-year term, and which body — directors or shareholders — should have the power to make these decisions. And participants in these and all of the other corporate governance discussions commonly assume that whatever seems to them to be the right answer to any given governance issue at any one time is the right answer for all companies, regardless of their particular circumstances.

It’s pretty hard to come to grips with the fundamentals, however, if you spend all of your time with the details. So the simple, but critical, first step in our 12-Step Program for truly good corporate governance is to start from the beginning. (continue reading… )


1 Response to “A 12-Step Program to Truly Good Corporate Governance”

  1. 1 Brian Finch May 19, 2011 at 3:20 pm

    Step One: Start at the Beginning — The Proper Goal of Corporate Governance is to Enhance Value Creation for Shareholders

    Well no, that is only one goal, and a very hard one to define at that. Corporate Governance is about balancing the interests of the different stakeholders in the business. The shareholders comprise one group of stakeholders – an important but not the only one – but it is a mistake to think of this as a homogeneous group. Some of them want short-term returns, others may adopt a long-term horizon and may be at odds with the first sub-group. So are we talking about enhancing short-term vale or long-term value – the results may be different?

    In so far as good governance should improve board efficiency there may be value creation for shareholders but equally good governance is about ensuring the management team do not capture an excessive share of the value that is available.

    Beyond that good governance is about ensuring that the company complies with laws and regulations, respects the community in which it operates, acts ethically etc. The old mantra about a company’s only duty being to maximise financial returns is inadequate because it ignores the ability of customers, suppliers, employees and the community generally to interfere with the company if their interests are ignored.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Blog coordinator

Cefeidas Group



free counters

%d bloggers like this: